Rabbi Dr. Tzvi Hersh Weinreb

A hostile train passenger taught me gratitude

Posted

He may or may not have been an antisemite, but he sure was an abrasive personality. He was my seatmate on an Amtrak train, returning from New York to Baltimore some years ago.

It was the end of a long and grueling day. I had a series of rabbinical meetings, delivered a lunchtime talk that left me no opportunity to eat, and tried, unsuccessfully, to keep a young couple’s marriage from breaking up. I was looking forward to some quiet time on the ride home, but even that luxury was denied me.

I sat down, as I always try to do, in the window seat. This fellow entered the car and walked past me in search of a seat. There were several he could have chosen, but for some reason he returned, glared at me and sat down with a gesture of dissatisfaction.

I sensed immediately that this would not be the peaceful ride I had anticipated. I buried my head in my book, but that was not sufficient insulation from my neighbor’s insistence upon conversation.

“You are obviously Jewish,” he began. “Your yarmulke is a dead giveaway. Plus, I see that you are reading a Hebrew book.”

I admitted to being Jewish and slanted my book in his direction so he could verify that it was indeed in Hebrew. I asked him, as I typically do in such conversations, whether he was Jewish.

I can only describe his response by saying that he snorted. “Look, buddy,” he growled. “I’ve got my bunch of problems and burdens, but being Jewish is thankfully not one of them.”

I was at a loss, but something about his use of the word “thankfully” prompted me to say: “But surely you have other things to be thankful for besides not being Jewish.”

He seemed taken aback, having expected me to be defensive or offended. I hoped I had succeeded in changing the topic from my Jewishness to his life and its blessings.

It worked, at least for a while. He said he didn’t have much to be thankful for, although he was happily married, had several children and held a well-paying job. These, he insisted, were merely good fortune and did not call for any expression of thanks.

• • •

Then he pressed on with his almost obsessive interest in my Jewishness. “Why do you Jews want to wear your Jewishness on the outside? Why do you dress so differently, and why do you persist in reading those old-fashioned books in that outdated language?”

I was about to launch into a lecture but restrained myself, knowing my efforts would be in vain. As I hesitated, he surprised me.

“Forget those questions,” he said. “I’ve asked many Jews this one, and none could give me a satisfactory answer: What does the word ‘Jew’ mean? What is its origin, and what is its significance?”

I then asked whether he was familiar with the Bible, particularly the Old Testament. His face, which until then had projected hostility, suddenly relaxed, and then his eyes clouded over with tears.

“Are you kidding? I was the child of a preacher whose father was a preacher before him. We read from the Bible at the dinner table and studied it every single day. I grew up resenting the Bible and all that it stood for, but I remember much of it against my will. I guess you can’t forget words that were ingrained in you since childhood.”

I now had my opening — and this is the connection to this week’s Torah reading, Vayetze (Genesis 28:10-32:3).

“Then you must remember the stories of Genesis. Do you recall the passage in which Leah names her children? Do you remember the name she gave her fourth son?”

The words came out of his mouth as if from a recording: “Genesis 29:35: And she conceived again and bore a son, and said, ‘This time I will praise the L-rd.’ Therefore she called his name Judah. Then she ceased bearing.”

He looked at me with a big grin, his face finally showing a small measure of friendship. “Impressive, wouldn’t you say? I remember every word. I even remember Grandpa explaining that ‘Judah’ sounds like the Hebrew for ‘praise’.”

I congratulated him on his excellent memory and remarked that he had his old Grandpa to thank for his biblical expertise. I added that in our tradition, Leah’s words are usually translated as, “This time I will thank the L-rd.”

• • •

“Now you have your answer,” I said. “We are called Jews because of our ancestor Judah, whose very name means to praise, or to thank. By definition, the Jew is a person who feels thankful, who expresses gratitude for all his blessings to the Almighty, and to the other humans without whose help those blessings would never be realized.”

He didn’t seem convinced. “Why then,” he pressed on, “is it so hard to feel thankful, and so much more difficult to express it?”

I told him that to answer, I would have to give him a further lesson in Hebrew. The word hoda’ah means thanks, but it also means admission, or confession. I shared something I had learned in the writings of Rabbi Isaac Hutner, who taught that when we thank another person, we are in effect admitting that we couldn’t do it alone, that we depended on the other person for the favor.

Gratitude to G-d entails recognizing our own insufficiency and confessing that without G-d, we would not have achieved that for which we are grateful.

“It is difficult to be thankful,” I concluded, “because it is difficult to admit to ourselves that alone we are inadequate, and that we must always rely upon the Divine or the human to achieve whatever we wish to achieve in life. We don’t like to admit that we need another, that we can’t ‘go it alone’.”

By then the train was fast approaching Wilmington, Delaware, where my companion was getting off. He didn’t say goodbye and certainly did not thank me for my words.

But he did give me a small bit of satisfaction. “You’re different from other Jews,” he said. “You actually make sense.”

I spent the rest of the ride pondering the adequacy of my responses to this stranger, and feeling thankful to the Almighty for giving me the words I needed to earn this dubious compliment.

Rabbi Dr. Tzvi Hersh Weinreb is executive vice president emeritus of the Orthodox Union.