James Sinkinson

Non-Jewish Dem showed courage Jews lacked

Posted

Michigan Rep. Haley Stevens, a lifelong Democrat, was prepared to go along to get along until two days before last week’s midterm elections. Stevens had lost Michigan’s Democratic Senate primary to Dr. Abdul El-Sayed, yet she loyally committed to supporting his candidacy.

Then came the “Banana Libel” ad, and she broke ranks.

The online ad, produced by Rebellion PAC, an outside group supporting the anti-Zionist El-Sayed, showed a couple in a grocery store returning eggs and bananas to the shelves because, as one character put it, “we have to set that $7 aside for killing Palestinians.” It slanderously held US aid to Israel responsible for rising supermarket prices and the deaths of innocents in war. It closed by casting El-Sayed’s Republican opponent, former Rep. Mike Rogers, as aligned with Israeli leaders, while El-Sayed was “for you.”

The messaging was so blatantly antisemitic — reviving the ancient trope that Jews and their state are responsible for ordinary people’s economic pain — that Stevens, who is not Jewish, demanded that El-Sayed disavow it. She also called on him to reject his own stump rhetoric, which similarly linked US aid to Israel with Michigan’s cost-of-living problems.

El-Sayed perfunctorily refused, dismissing the demand as a “condemn game” and a distraction. His campaign noted that it had nothing to do with the ad, but he would neither condemn its content nor apologize for the underlying argument he had advanced himself.

When Stevens then endorsed Rogers, her Democratic colleagues, including Senate Minority Leader Chuck Schumer, immediately piled on, accusing her of betrayal. Yet for those who place Jewish peoplehood and American values above party loyalty, Stevens is a courageous hero. She stood alone as a patriot and will pay a high price for her bravery, as patriots sometimes do.

• • •

The shame is that so few American Jews have had the guts to stand up and rebuke the Democratic Party, with which some 70% of US Jews identify, as Stevens did. Of course, Jews are not alone. A majority of voters in last week’s election also ignored the dire threat that anti-American candidates pose both to the safety of Jews and to our nation’s fundamental political and economic principles.

Let’s make no mistake. While Jews are most directly attacked by antisemites such as El-Sayed and his ilk, a greater danger looms in the disdain these rising politicians express for our country and its values, which allow all of us, including minorities like Jews, to survive and thrive. El-Sayed, now Michigan’s senator-elect, will be joined by dozens of Democratic Socialists of America members elected to offices nationwide, as well as seven new anti-Israel members of the US House.

Jews are irrevocably associated with Israel as the homeland of the Jewish people and with the Star of David on Israel’s flag. El-Sayed opposes Israel and supports those who traffic in antisemitic tropes, such as far-left streamer Hasan Piker. Like others in this faction, such as Mayor Zohran Mamdani, he has disparaged and refused to defend Jewish communities as they face rising hostility.

As Stevens herself pointed out, the ad did not invent its argument; it dramatized one El-Sayed made throughout the campaign.

Although aid to Israel makes up a tiny portion of the annual US budget — one-twentieth of 1% — El-Sayed implies that Michiganders cannot afford schools, health care or child care because of Israel. This libel alone deserves the outrage and activism of American Jews.

Antisemitism is fundamentally anti-American and should be condemned by every patriotic American. To single out the Jewish state for blame over grocery prices while ignoring far larger drivers of inflation, domestic spending and global markets is not serious policy debate. It is hateful scapegoating. Stevens recognized this and refused to stay silent.

Moreover, contrary to the ad’s message, anti-Israelism and anti-Zionism deny the immense benefit the US-Israel relationship brings to Americans. The annual military investment the United States makes in Israel delivers major strategic returns — through intelligence-sharing, joint technology development and a reliable democratic ally in a volatile region.

• • •

The two nations’ political and military cooperation advances US security and prosperity, especially since Israel spends about 90% of US aid with American military suppliers. Aid to Israel also spares the United States from putting American boots on the ground, as Washington does in Germany and Japan at costs that dwarf the paltry amount of aid to Israel. In short, opposing a close US-Israel relationship compromises American security by weakening a key partner against shared Middle East adversaries.

Finally, to oppose Zionism — the self-determination of an indigenous people in their ancestral homeland — is itself anti-American. This opposition rejects the same principles of national self-determination that undergird our own founding.

The next election is the big one, and it is just a heartbeat away. Winning it means speaking up on behalf of the Jewish people and the Jewish state. It means standing up for American security, prosperity and national values that are increasingly under attack from within. Above all, it means initiating painful conversations with Democratic faithful who put party above peoplehood and country.

Stevens showed that party loyalty has limits when core principles are at stake. Her colleagues’ immediate scorn revealed how deeply the progressive wing has normalized antisemitic tropes under the guise of foreign-policy critique. Voters who ignored the pattern did so at the risk of elevating candidates who view America’s alliances and foundational principles as obstacles rather than assets.

Haley Stevens, the non-Jewish Democrat who refused to look away, has set a high standard. May the rest of us patriots — Jewish and non-Jewish alike — follow her example. Come the next election cycle, the cost of silence will be even more painful.

James Sinkinson is president of Facts and Logic About the Middle East (FLAME).