Seven employees of the New York City Department of Health and Mental Hygiene have sued the city, the department and its equal employment opportunity director, alleging that the agency refused to recognize a Jewish employee group and then retaliated by investigating the group’s leaders after they mourned the Jews killed at Bondi Beach in Australia.
The lawsuit, filed Nov. 10 by the National Jewish Advocacy Center in US District Court for the Southern District of New York, accuses department officials of denying the group, Hinenu, access to a program available to other ethnic groups. The department also opened an “unfounded investigation” into statements by eight of the group’s leaders about Jew-hatred and terrorism, the center said.
Health officials first refused to allow a Jewish employee resource group in July 2025, on the grounds that such a group’s “identity cannot be based on religious groups,” according to the complaint.
The group sought the same benefits the department provides to six other employee resource groups, including an agency email account, an internal web page and an annual budget of $5,000.
The department did recognize a group for staff of Southwest Asian and North African ancestry, whose charter “encompasses multiple religious identities,” the plaintiffs allege.
Hinenu’s charter stated that it “will not engage in political advocacy, religious worship or religious instruction” and that it “is not organized to advance, oppose or practice any religion,” according to the complaint.
Alan Scheiner, a lawyer with the National Jewish Advocacy Center, told JNS that the group is “not asking the agency to fund Jewish religious services.”
“That would be improper,” he said. “We’re asking them to recognize that Jews are an ethnicity, an ancestry, a cultural heritage, and allow us to celebrate that and associate according to that shared heritage.”
“They denied it under the assumption, which is false — and I think they know it’s false, actually, for reasons we allege in the complaint — that Jews are just a religion, and that any association of Jews is a religious association,” Scheiner said.
The plaintiffs seek a court order requiring the department to recognize Hinenu on equal terms with other employee groups and to expunge the investigation from its records. They are also asking for damages and legal fees.
Six of the seven plaintiffs are Jewish. The seventh, Joanna Micius, has “a strong interest in Judaism,” according to Scheiner, and alleges that the department discriminated against her because of her association with Jewish colleagues.
On Dec. 16, 2025, Hinenu used its agency email account to send about 85 city employees a holiday message mourning the Jews killed two days earlier at a Chanukah celebration at Sydney’s Bondi Beach.
The message quoted Rabbi Chaim Steinmetz, senior rabbi of Congregation Kehilath Jeshurun, a Modern Orthodox synagogue on Manhattan’s Upper East Side, who said that “globalizing the intifada is a call to murder” and that “anti-Zionism kills Jews.”
The next day, Hinenu appealed to senior department leaders for support. Within hours, Sye-Eun Ahn, the department’s equal employment opportunity director, ordered the group to “desist” from using its agency email account, according to the complaint.
On Dec. 18, the group held an online support session for employees distressed by the attack.
Fourteen colleagues, most of whom had neither received the email nor attended the session, then complained, the lawsuit alleges, and the department opened a several-month long investigation of eight of the group’s leaders for what it called “racial and religious discrimination.”
When investigators questioned the group’s leaders in April, they focused on the employees’ views about Zionism, Israel and the slogan “globalize the intifada.”
The sessions were “very reminiscent” of
“struggle sessions, where the supposed offenders are harangued until they confess to having engaged in some type of political crime,” Scheiner said.
One investigator asked whether the Bondi Beach massacre was “an antisemitic attack or an anti-Zionist attack,” acknowledging, “I know it’s a loaded question,” the lawsuit alleges.
Another investigator asked whether quoting Steinmetz was “something that could be potentially inflammatory and something that strays a little different from creating a safe space.”
The department “didn’t at all recognize or support the grief of the Jews and also Israeli immigrants who work for the Department of Health,” Scheiner said. “They had no empathy for the feelings of the Jews about that horrific attack on Jews, who were trying to observe Chanukah at Bondi Beach in Australia.”
The department closed the probes on June 24, saying it was “unable to make findings” because it could not adopt “a definitive interpretation of terms and slogans such as ‘anti-Zionism’ and ‘globalize the intifada’,” according to the lawsuit.
Hinenu formally applied for recognition six days later. Ahn rejected the application on July 10, the lawsuit states.
The plaintiffs contrast the scrutiny of their statements with the department’s own programming about Israel. At a Feb. 3 workshop at department headquarters, an agency official told more than 100 attendees that its “global oppression working group” had been “developed in response to the ongoing genocide in Palestine,” according to the complaint.
The department, Scheiner said, “took up the cause of Israel’s enemies and adopted almost as an article of faith, or rather as policy of the Department of Health, that Israel was engaged in a genocide almost immediately after Oct. 7 occurred.”
The lawsuit alleges that the department’s treatment of Hinenu reflects a broader city policy hostile to Jews under Mayor Zohran Mamdani, who appoints the health commissioner.
After the city recorded a 182% increase in anti-Jewish hate crimes in January, Mamdani’s first month in office, it began publishing only “confirmed” hate crimes, not “reported” ones, in February. The change suggested a decline, though it made 2026 figures hard to compare with those from 2025.
In March, the city said it would publish “confirmed” and “reported” figures separately each month. It compares “confirmed” 2026 figures with the prior year, but not “reported” ones.
Statistics the city released earlier this month show that Jews, who make up about 11% of New Yorkers, were the targets of 57.8% of the city’s hate crimes in October and 52.6% of all hate crimes so far this year.
Some of the conduct alleged in the lawsuit predates Mamdani’s tenure, but “there is this strong link between the agency’s policy of denying Jewish peoplehood and the overall, we believe, policy of the city — antisemitic policy of the city — which is expressed primarily in the mayor’s relentless hostility to Israel,” Scheiner said.
He acknowledged that the plaintiffs “don’t have any direct evidence that City Hall knew of the denial of the employee resource group, or that they planned or knew of the event on Feb. 3, 2026.”
But the “agency-wide lecture about the alleged evils of Israel” had “no connection to the work of the agency and yet consumed agency time and resources,” he said.
Mamdani is partly responsible for an “antisemitic culture” that the health department adopted, according to Scheiner.
“Israel is only a tiny part of the population of the world, as are Jews, only a tiny fraction, less than 0.2% of the world,” he said. “For that to be the singular, repetitive, pervasive focus of the agency is really quite remarkable.”
“To us, it’s obviously antisemitic, because it’s not a coincidence that Israel is the only Jewish state and Israel is the only foreign state that is subject to the ire of the city of New York’s executive and the Department of Health,” he said. —JNS