In Denmark, a happy Shoah commemoration


COPENHAGEN, Denmark — All over the world, Holocaust commemoration events follow a certain protocol. Somber affairs where participants dress in dark colors, they might feature a soulful “Kel Malei Rachamim” sung by an anguished cantor who names Nazi death camps and the horrible ways Jews were murdered there.

Less traditional ceremonies may include a low-key mourning song, often from Israel, and “Hatikvah,” the Israeli national anthem.

Not so in Denmark, the only country where nearly all Jews were rescued by the local population in a grassroots operation that involved thousands of people. Seventy-five years ago, 7,200 Jews from the Nazi-occupied Scandinavian land were ferried aboard small ships to neutral Sweden in a matter of just a few days.

The annual commemoration here occurs on the anniversary of the rescue. There is mourning for the 51 Danish Jews who died in the genocide. But it is mostly a cheerful event where one unique community unites to celebrate its rescue amid song, backslapping, and sometimes a festive communal dinner.

On Oct. 11, hundreds filled the Great Synagogue of Copenhagen to capacity, greeting Crown Prince Federik with a silent ovation and Israeli President Reuven Rivlin with a roaring one. Susanne Bier, an Oscar-winning Jewish director, wore a tight red dress reminiscent of gala wear. The ceremony ended with an upbeat performance by a girls’ choir from a Jewish school singing “Ya’ase Shalom” and a patriotic Danish song by national writer Hans Christian Andersen.

“This ceremony has some sadness for those who didn’t make it and for our brethren who perished,” said Helle Fromberg, a kindergarten teacher whose mother was rescued. “But inevitably it’s also a celebration of the rescue, without which most of the people here would not be alive today.”

Fromberg and her husband, Norway-born Thomas Gorlen, celebrate how the Danish resistance movement made the country a hospitable place for Jews right up to the present.

“There is this mentality here that it doesn’t matter so much who or what you are as long as you follow the rules and integrate,” he said. “And Danish Jews did, so they were never seen as the ‘other.’”

The couple, who lived together in Norway, are “very happy we ended up settling in Denmark and raising our children here,” Fromberg said. Denmark’s history means that “the Jewish community is more self-assured and belonging” than in countries where Jews were killed by the Nazis, often with collaboration by locals.

“Throughout most of Europe, police helped the Nazis kill the Jews,” Fromberg said. “Here, police helped the Jews escape the Nazis.”

There are other ways in which Denmark contrasted with the rest of Nazi-controlled Europe.

Annelise Tchernia, 79, recalls finding her family’s home “exactly as we left it” when she and her parents returned from Sweden three years after their escape, which was carried out with the help of their family doctor, resistance hero Borghild Andersson.

Andersson also took care of Tchernia’s childhood home, letting those in need of housing stay there — on condition that they leave as soon as the owners return. While some Danish Jews did lose property, its return in full to others is unheard of anywhere else in Europe.

In Denmark, concern for the Jews ran all the way to the top.

King Christian X did not, contrary to popular myth, ride his horse through Copenhagen wearing the Star of David. But he did make it clear, as he wrote in his diary, that he considered “our own Jews to be Danish citizens, and the Germans could not touch them.”

Danish Prime Minister Laros Lokke Rasmussen echoed those words during his Oct. 11 speech at the synagogue.

“An attack on Danish Jews,” he said, “is an attack on Denmark.”

Still, Danish Jewry’s rescue had less photogenic aspects. Many of the fishermen who transported the Jews across the Oresund Strait to Sweden demanded payment. Tchernia remembers that on the eve of her family’s departure, her father called his bank manager after hours to receive cash to pay for the boat ride.

But she is not bitter.

“The fisherman who took us across was so scared that the Germans would come for him after they found out the Jews had gone that he stayed in Sweden,” she said. “He needed some money to get by, too.”

Tchernia’s father looked for a crossing point for days before he found the captain. At one point he arrived in Gilleleje, a fishing village 40 miles north of Copenhagen, where locals hid 86 Jews in an attic before the Nazis discovered them. A refugee from Russia who grew up hearing about pogroms, the father “took one look and said there were too many people in one small place,” and took his family elsewhere, Tchernia said.

On Sept. 26, the Hebrew anniversary of the crossing, she and dozens of other Danish Jews attended a reenactment organized by Rabbi Yitzi and Rochel Loewenthal, Chabad emissaries in Denmark. The event featured a klezmer band and testimonies by survivors like Tchernia.

Despite the gratitude she feels to the Danes who saved her family, Tchernia and others living in Denmark today say the tolerance that inspired the operation has diminished following a backlash against Muslim immigrants.

Over the past decade, Denmark has developed some of Europe’s strictest immigration policies, which The Washington Post last year called “a Muslim ban [that] was just called something else.” The country is now preparing to vote on a parliamentary resolution whose premise is that nonmedical circumcision of boys is a form of child abuse.

“It’s not safe to wear a kippah on the street,” Tchernia said, noting the 2015 murder of a Jewish guard, Dan Uzan, outside the synagogue by a jihadist. Anti-Semitic violence in Denmark mostly comes from Muslims, “But it’s not only Muslims who are creating the problem. It’s changed the whole society.”

Rochel Lowenthal wonders if the Danish Holocaust story would have been different had the country’s Jews, like today’s Muslims, been more easily identifiable as outsiders.

“Danish Jews were always very integrated,” said Lowenthal, who like her husband wears the distinctive modest garb of haredi Orthodox Jews.

“And I can’t help but wonder if they would almost all have been rescued if they looked like me and my husband.”